-
Why Grant Thornton
Whether you’re growing in one market or many, looking to operate more effectively, managing risk and regulation, or realising stakeholder value, our firms can help.
-
Culture and experience
Grant Thornton’s culture is one of our most valuable assets and has steered us in the right direction for more than 100 years.
-
Global scale and capability
Beyond global scale, we embrace what makes each market unique, local understanding on a global scale.
-
Join our network
In a world that wants more options for high quality services, we differentiate in the market to grow sustainably in today’s rapidly changing environment.
-
Leadership governance and quality
Grant Thornton International Ltd acts as the coordinating entity for member firms in the network with a focus on areas such as strategy, risk, quality monitoring and brand.
-
Africa
24 member firms supporting your business.
-
Americas
31 member firms, covering 44 markets and over 20,000 people.
-
Asia-Pacific
19 member firms with nearly 25,000 people to support you.
-
Europe
53 member firms supporting your business.
-
Middle East
8 member firms supporting your business.
-
Business consulting services
Our business consulting services can help you improve your operational performance and productivity, adding value throughout your growth life cycle.
-
Business process solutions
We can help you identify, understand and manage potential risks to safeguard your business and comply with regulatory requirements.
-
Business risk services
The relationship between a company and its auditor has changed. Organisations must understand and manage risk and seek an appropriate balance between risk and opportunities.
-
Cybersecurity
As organisations become increasingly dependent on digital technology, the opportunities for cyber criminals continue to grow.
-
Forensic services
At Grant Thornton, we have a wealth of knowledge in forensic services and can support you with issues such as dispute resolution, fraud and insurance claims.
-
Mergers and acquisitions
We work with entrepreneurial businesses in the mid-market to help them assess the true commercial potential of their planned acquisition and understand how the purchase might serve their longer-term strategic goals.
-
Recovery and reorganisation
Workable solutions to maximise your value and deliver sustainable recovery.
-
Transactional advisory services
We can support you throughout the transaction process – helping achieve the best possible outcome at the point of the transaction and in the longer term.
-
Valuations
We provide a wide range of services to recovery and reorganisation professionals, companies and their stakeholders.
-
IFRS
At Grant Thornton, our IFRS advisers can help you navigate the complexity of financial reporting from IFRS 1 to IFRS 17 and IAS 1 to IAS 41.
-
Audit quality monitoring
Having a robust process of quality control is one of the most effective ways to guarantee we deliver high-quality services to our clients.
-
Global audit technology
Our global assurance technology platform provides the ability to conduct client acceptance, consultations and all assurance and other attestation engagements.
-
Corporate and business tax
Our trusted teams can prepare corporate tax files and ruling requests, support you with deferrals, accounting procedures and legitimate tax benefits.
-
Direct international tax
Our teams have in-depth knowledge of the relationship between domestic and international tax laws.
-
Global mobility services
Through our global organisation of member firms, we support both companies and individuals, providing insightful solutions to minimise the tax burden for both parties.
-
Indirect international tax
Using our finely tuned local knowledge, teams from our global organisation of member firms help you understand and comply with often complex and time-consuming regulations.
-
Transfer pricing
The laws surrounding transfer pricing are becoming ever more complex, as tax affairs of multinational companies are facing scrutiny from media, regulators and the public
-
Africa tax desk
A differentiating solution adapted to the context of your investments in Africa.
-
Banking Holding banking to account: the real diversity and inclusion pictureWe explore how the banking sector can continue to attract, retain and nurture women to build a more diverse and inclusive future.
-
Sustainability From voluntary to mandatory ESG: How banks can future-proof their operationsAs we move from voluntary ESG initiatives to mandatory legislation, we explore what the banking sector needs to prioritise.
-
IFRS IFRS 9 - Audit of Expected Credit LossesGPPC releases The Auditor’s response to the risks of material misstatement posed by estimates of expected credit losses under IFRS 9
-
growthiQ Steering your company to long-term successHistory has something important to tell us about the difficulties of steering a business to long-term success – through seismic shifts in technology, consumer demands and product development. With that in mind it’s unsurprising that over half the world’s largest companies in the early 1900s had shut their doors by the late 1990s. Some, however, have endured.
-
International Financial Reporting Standards Implementation of IFRS 17 ‘Insurance Contracts’The auditor’s response to the risks of material misstatement arising from estimates made in applying IFRS 17 ‘Insurance Contracts’
-
IFRS Get ready for IFRS 17After twenty years of development the IASB has published IFRS 17 ‘Insurance Contracts’, find out more.
-
Global business pulse - industry analysis Mid-market recovery spreads to more industriesThe index results for 13 key industries of the mid-market reveals a very uneven recovery from COVID-19
-
Global business pulse - industry analysis A very uneven recovery across industriesThe index results for 13 key industries of the mid-market reveals a very uneven recovery from COVID-19
-
Global business pulse - Sector analysis Clear patterns of damage from COVID-19 across the industriesThe index results for 12 key sectors of the mid-market reveal just how much or little the various parts of the economy were impacted by COVID-19.
-
Not for profit Mission: possible – putting impact at the heart of charityGlobal charitable continues to decline and charity leaders are increasingly looking at their own unique impact journey.
-
Access to finance Raise finance to invest in changePrepare your business to raise finance to invest in change.
-
Private equity firms Private equity in the mid-market: reshaping strategies for 2021When the global COVID-19 pandemic stormed across the globe in early 2020, the private equity sector was hit hard but deals are coming back to the market.
-
Mid-market businesses Getting ready for private equity investmentOur specialists explore how private equity firms are now working with their portfolios and how the mid-market can benefit from investment.
-
Mid-market businesses Myth-busting private equityNervous about partnering with Private Equity? We explore some of the common myths we come across when speaking to mid-market businesses about PE investment.
-
Public sector Helping build the government of tomorrow, todayLearn about the Grant Thornton US public sector team.
-
Global business pulse - industry analysis Mid-market recovery spreads to more industriesThe index results for 13 key industries of the mid-market reveals a very uneven recovery from COVID-19
-
Global business pulse - industry analysis A very uneven recovery across industriesThe index results for 13 key industries of the mid-market reveals a very uneven recovery from COVID-19
-
Global business pulse - Sector analysis Clear patterns of damage from COVID-19 across the industriesThe index results for 12 key sectors of the mid-market reveal just how much or little the various parts of the economy were impacted by COVID-19.
-
Industries European Real Estate PodcastJessica Patel, Tax Partner at Grant Thornton UK speaks with tax partners and directors across the network to share their insights on the real estate market and some of the challenges.
-
Industries European Real Estate PodcastJessica Patel, Tax Partner at Grant Thornton UK speaks with tax partners and directors across the network to share their insights on the real estate market and some of the challenges.
-
Global business pulse - industry analysis Mid-market recovery spreads to more industriesThe index results for 13 key industries of the mid-market reveals a very uneven recovery from COVID-19
-
Global business pulse - industry analysis A very uneven recovery across industriesThe index results for 13 key industries of the mid-market reveals a very uneven recovery from COVID-19
-
-
Global business pulse - industry analysis Mid-market recovery spreads to more industriesThe index results for 13 key industries of the mid-market reveals a very uneven recovery from COVID-19
-
Global business pulse - industry analysis A very uneven recovery across industriesThe index results for 13 key industries of the mid-market reveals a very uneven recovery from COVID-19
-
Retail How retail is positioning for successCOVID-19 provided some hard lessons for the retail industry. It is time to turn those into sustainable and well executed growth strategies in 2021.
-
Telecoms Can tech and telecom leverage economic headwindsAs most businesses brace for an economic downturn, tech and telecom could see new prospects. But, to turn the headwinds to your advantage, you need to find your unique opportunities and risks.
-
Technology Mid-market tech companies lead the way on diversity and inclusionWe explore how the mid-market tech sector can continue to build and nurture a culture that’s increasingly more diverse and inclusive for women.
-
Tax Resetting global tax rules after the pandemicBusinesses are seeing rising challenges, and finance heads are dealing with a range of new measures. To say the next 12 months are critical for businesses is an understatement.
-
TECHNOLOGY International tax reform: the potential impact on the technology industryIn this article, we’ve summarised key elements of the global tax reform proposals, their potential impact on technology industry and advice from our digital tax specialists on what technology companies can do to prepare.
-
Telecoms Can tech and telecom leverage economic headwindsAs most businesses brace for an economic downturn, tech and telecom could see new prospects. But, to turn the headwinds to your advantage, you need to find your unique opportunities and risks.
-
TMT TMT industry: Fully charged or on standby?Our research revealed five key trends that resonated with Technology, Media and Telecoms (TMT) industry leaders around the world. We asked a panel of our experts from UK, US, India Ireland and Germany, to give us their reaction to the findings.
-
Cybersecurity One size fits nothingTechnology companies must adopt a new approach to digital risk: those that successfully develop a reputation for digital trust by demonstrating an unwavering commitment to cyber security and data privacy will be able to carve out a competitive advantage.
-
Technology, media & telecommunications Why it’s time for a 5G reality checkFigures suggest the mobile sector is maturing. While data usage continues to soar, mobile revenues are expected to flatten out over the next few years.
-
International business Mid-market businesses lifted by rising tide of optimismOptimism among global mid-market business leaders rose to 67% in the first half of this year and they are markedly more optimistic about their prospects with global optimism having increased by 8%.
-
Global business pulse - industry analysis Mid-market recovery spreads to more industriesThe index results for 13 key industries of the mid-market reveals a very uneven recovery from COVID-19
-
Hotels COVID-19: Checking in with the hotel industry one year onCOVID-19 provided some hard lessons for the hotel sector. It is time to turn those into sustainable and well executed growth strategies.
-
Global business pulse - industry analysis A very uneven recovery across industriesThe index results for 13 key industries of the mid-market reveals a very uneven recovery from COVID-19
- By topic
-
Women in Business 2024
2024 marks the 20th year of monitoring and measuring the proportion of women occupying senior management roles around the world.
-
COP28: Mid-market firms should seize the opportunity from adaption and innovation
COP28 was the first time there has been a global stocktake on progress against the Paris Agreement.
-
Scanning the horizon: Mid-market sets sights on global trade growth
The latest International Business Report (IBR) data shows that mid-market businesses have high expectations for global trade.
-
Mid-market sees business optimism reach record high
Grant Thornton's latest International Business Report (IBR) sees optimism among mid-market business leaders reach a record high with 74% optimistic about the outlook for their economy over the next 12 months.
-
Women in tech: A pathway to gender balance in top tech roles
Grant Thornton’s 2024 Women in Business data suggests we are far from achieving parity within the mid-market technology sector.
-
Women in leadership: a pathway to better performance
What makes the benefits of gender parity compelling is the impact it can have on commercial performance.
-
Women in Business 2024
2024 marks the 20th year of monitoring and measuring the proportion of women occupying senior management roles around the world.
-
Women in business: Regional picture
We saw an increase in the percentage of senior management roles held by women, on a global level, but there are some significant regional and country variations.
-
Pathways to Parity: Leading the way
To push towards parity of senior management roles held by women, who leads within an organisation is vital.
-
Generating real change with a long-term focus
The most successful strategy to achieve parity of women in senior management is one which stands alone, independent of an ESG strategy.
-
People at the heart of great business
Businesses have started to put guidelines and incentives in place, focused on driving employees back to the office.
-
Focusing and developing a solid strategy around diversity, equity and inclusion
Grant Thornton Greece is pioneering a growing set of diversity, equity and inclusion (DE&I) initiatives that centre around three strategic pillars.
-
Ten considerations for preparing TCFD climate-related financial disclosures
Insights for organisations preparing to implement the International Sustainability Standards Board (ISSB)’s Standards.
-
COP28
COP28 was the first time there has been a global stocktake on progress against the Paris Agreement.
-
Transition Plan Taskforce publishes its final disclosure framework
As organisations in the private sector make commitments and plans to reach net zero, there's a growing need for stakeholders to be able to assess the credibility of their transition plans.
-
Promoting ESG excellence through tax
ESG considerations have never been more important for an organisation’s long-term success, but how can tax be used to add value to an ESG agenda?
-
International business: Mid-market growth and expansion
The mid-market looks to international business opportunities for growth.
-
Top five constraints to international business in the mid-market
Top five major constraints that are testing the mid-market’s ability to grow their businesses internationally.
-
Brand and international marketing – breaking global barriers
Brand has been identified as a key driver of mid-market success when looking to grow and develop international business.
-
The key to international business: Investing in people
How can recruitment and retention help grow international business?
-
Building resilience in international business
Evolving supply chains and trade patterns amid ongoing global uncertainty.
-
IFRS Alerts
IFRS Alerts covering the latest changes published by the International Accounting Standards Board (IASB).
-
Example Financial Statements
General guidance for preparers of financial statements that supports the commitment to high quality, consistent application of IFRS.
-
Insights into IFRS 2
Insights into IFRS 2 summarises the key areas of the Standard, highlighting aspects that are more difficult to interpret and revisiting the most relevant features that could impact your business.
-
IFRS 3
Mergers and acquisitions are becoming more common as entities aim to achieve their growth objectives. IFRS 3 ‘Business Combinations’ contains the requirements for these transactions.
-
IFRS 8
Our ‘Insights into IFRS 8’ series considers some key implementation issues and includes interpretational guidance in certain problematic areas.
-
IFRS 16
Are you ready for IFRS 16? This series of insights will help you prepare.
-
IAS 36
Insights into IAS 36 provides assistance for preparers of financial statements and help where confusion has been seen in practice.
-
IFRS 17
Explaining the key features of the Standard and providing insights into its application and impact.
-
Pillar 2
Key updates and support for the global implementation of Pillar 2.
-
Global expatriate tax guide
Growing businesses that send their greatest assets – their people – overseas to work can face certain tax burdens, our global guide highlights the common tax rates and issues.
-
International indirect tax guide
Navigating the global VAT, GST and sales tax landscape.
-
Global transfer pricing guide
Helping you easily find everything you need to know about the rules and regulations regarding transfer pricing and Country by Country reporting for every country you do business with.
Accounting implications for CFOs
The COVID-19 global pandemic has resulted in economic consequences that many reporting entities may not have had to previously consider. One of those consequences is their ability to repay loans. In response, some lenders have agreed to changing the borrowing terms or providing waivers or modifications to debt covenant arrangements. Any changes to the terms of loan agreements, for example providing any kind of payment holidays on either principal or interest or changing interest rates, should be carefully assessed.
Borrowers need to determine the impact of these changes and then apply the guidance set out in IFRS 9 ‘Financial Instruments’ to determine whether the change is a modification (as defined in IFRS 9). In many instances, a gain or a loss might need to be recorded in profit or loss and depending on facts and circumstances, derecognition of the financial arrangement might be required as a result of modifying the financial instrument arrangement that existed.
Debt modification accounting
Debt restructuring can take various legal forms including:
- an amendment to the terms of a debt instrument (eg the amounts and timing of payments of interest and principal) or
- a notional repayment of existing debt with immediate re-lending of the same or a different amount with the same counterparty. The borrower will usually incur costs in a debt restructuring, and other fees might also be paid or received. The accounting for the debt modification depends on whether it considered to be ‘substantial’ or ‘non-substantial’.
There are two tests to check whether the modification is substantial, and these are as follows:
- Qualitative test - A significant change in the terms and conditions such that immediate derecognition is required with no additional quantitative analysis.
Examples of this type of modification include issuing new debt in different currency from old debt, or equity instrument embedded in the new debt. - Quantitative test - The net present value of the cash flows under the new terms discounted at the original effective interest rate (EIR) is at least 10% different from the carrying amount of the original debt. This is described as the ‘10% test’.
The following flowchart sets out how to assess whether or not a debt modification is substantial:
The role of fees in the 10% test
As mentioned above, if the ‘10% test’ is exceeded in the quantitative test, this results in a substantial modification. IFRS 9 states this test should compare the discounted present value amount of the cash flows under the new term, including any fees paid net of any fees received, discounted at the original EIR, with the discounted present value amount of the remaining cash flows of the original liability.
As this test is comparing the extent of the change between borrower and lender, the reference to fees in this context should refer to the fees between borrower and lender (eg would not normally include fees paid a lawyer). This was clarified by an amendment to IFRS 9 in the ‘Annual Improvements to IFRS Standards 2018-2020’ issued on 14 May 2020. Whereas above, in the final step, the fees included as an adjustment to the EIR are all fees, including external fees (such as lawyer fees).
In addition, these amendments also clarify that when the exchange or modification is not accounted for as an extinguishment, any costs or fees incurred adjust the carrying amount of the liability and are amortised over the remaining term of the modified liability. If they are accounted for as an extinguishment, they are recognised as part of the gain or loss on the extinguishment that should be recognised in profit or loss.
Modification accounting
IFRS 9 contains guidance on non-substantial modifications and the accounting in such cases. It states that costs or fees incurred are adjusted against the liability and are amortised over the remaining term. That same guidance is silent on other changes in cash flows. Prior to IFRS 9, IAS 39 ‘Financial Instruments: Recognition and Measurement’ included similar guidance, and under IAS 39 it was common for entities to account for non-substantial modifications on a ‘no gain no loss’ basis.
However, IFRS 9 clarifies in the Basis for Conclusions the IASB intends that adjustments to amortised cost in such cases should be recognised in profit or loss. This is the consequence of applying IFRS 9, according to which the liability should be restated to its revised future cash flows discounted by the original EIR.
Entity X has a non-amortising loan of CU 1,000,000 from a bank. Interest is set at a fixed rate of 5%, which is payable monthly. Maturity date is 31 Dec 2022. Transaction costs are assessed to be Nil, meaning the EIR equals the contractual interest of 5%.
On 1 July 2020, the bank agrees to waive interest for a six month period from 1 July 2020 to 31 December 2020.
Analysis
The value of the non-discounted cash flows before the waiver, discounted at the original EIR is CU 1,000,000 (ie the amortised cost before the waiver). The value of the non-discounted cash flows after the waiver (with six months of less payments), discounted at the original EIR of 5%, gives a new amortised cost of CU 976,000.
In terms of the 10% test, CU 976,000 is less than 10% different to the previous carrying amount, therefore this is treated as a non-substantial modification. The liability is restated in accordance with IFRS 9 to the net present value of future cash flows discounted at 5%, which is CU 976,000.
The difference is an immediate gain of CU 24,000 (CU 1,000,000-CU 976,000) which is recognised in the profit or loss. During the periods where no interest is paid, the interest charge in the profit or loss will continue to be presented, by applying the EIR (adjusted, if need be, for any fees relating to the modification) to the revised amortised cost of the instrument.
The following journal should be recorded:
Journal: | CU | CU |
Dr Existing liability | 24,000 | |
Cr Profit or loss | 24,000 |
Fees paid in a non-substantial modification
As explained above, in a non-substantial modification, the liability is restated based on the net present value of the revised cash flows discounted at the original EIR. This amount is compared to the previous carrying amount and the difference is recognised in the profit or loss. However IFRS 9 specifically states in its application guidance, that costs or fees incurred are adjusted against the carrying amount. Such costs or fees therefore have some impact of altering the EIR rather than being recognised in the profit or loss.
Where the counterparty bank is paid an amount which is described as a fee, it would appear contradictory to IFRS 9 to amortise this. In our view, fees to third parties such as lawyers fees should be amortised (and the EIR adjusted). However, we believe fees paid to the counterparty bank that represent part of the cash flows should normally be accounted for in the same way as other as other cash flows on the debt instrument, which would lead to such fees being part of the gain or loss rather than amortised over the remaining life of the loan.
Assume the same scenario as the first example, however there are two additional facts. As part of this modification the entity:
- incurs a CU 10,000 arrangement fee from the bank
- incurs CU 5,000 of legal fees.
Analysis
The entity carries out the 10% test:
The net present value of the future cash flows, (discounted at the original EIR inclusive of fees paid to the lender) is CU 976,000 plus CU 10,000 = CU 986,000.
For the purposes of the 10% test this is compared to CU 1,000,000 giving only a 1.4% difference. This is less than 10%, so the loan modification (waiver of 6 months of interest) considered to be a non-substantial modification.
However, for the purposes of the accounting entries, our view is the fees to the lender should be expensed while the legal fees should be amortised as explained above.
Therefore, the following journal entries should be recorded:
Journal: | CU | CU |
Dr Existing liability | 24,000 | |
Cr Profit or loss (modification gain) | 24,000 | |
Cr Cash (costs and fees paid) | 15,000 | |
Dr Existing liability (legal fees) | 5,000 | |
Dr Profit or loss (bank fees) | 10,000 |
Extinguishment accounting
Extinguishment accounting involves:
- de-recognition of the existing liability
- recognition of the new or modified liability at its fair value
- recognition of a gain or loss equal to the difference between the carrying value of the old liability and the fair value of the new one. Any incremental costs or fees incurred, and any consideration paid or received, are also included in the calculation of the gain or loss, and
- calculating a new EIR for the modified liability, that is then used in future periods. This rate would normally equate to the market rate of interest used in the fair value calculation (see below).
The fair value of the modified liability will usually need to be estimated. It cannot be assumed that the fair value equals the book value of the existing liability. The fair value can be estimated based on the expected future cash flows of the modified liability, discounted using the interest rate at which the entity could raise debt with similar terms and conditions in the market.
One effect of extinguishment accounting is the accelerated ‘expensing’ of transaction costs. This is because the unamortised portion of any transaction costs deducted from the original loan is included in the determination of the gain or loss on extinguishment. Any additional fees or costs incurred on modification are also included in the gain or loss.
There are some narrow exceptions to this, but generally this is only where the fees do not clearly relate to the modification, but are incremental to issuing the new debt that is payable to a party other than the lender, eg stamp duty paid on new financial instrument that is put in place.
Entity X has a non-amortising loan of CU 10,000,000 from the bank. Interest is set at a fixed rate of 5%, which is payable quarterly. Maturity date is 31 December 2025.
On 1 July 2020 the bank agrees to waive interest for two quarterly periods from 1 July 2020 to 31 December 2020. In addition, the contractual rate of interest is increased to 8% starting 1 January 2021.
As part of the modification, the entity pays a CU 150,000 arrangement fee to the bank and a CU 50,000 professional service fee to its lawyers.
Analysis
The entity carries out the 10% test:
- the net present value of the future revised cash flows, discounted at the original EIR inclusive of fees paid to the lender is CU 10,990,426 plus CU 150,000 which is equal to CU 11,140,426.
- for the purposes of the 10% test this is compared to CU 10,000,000 giving an 11.4% difference. This is more than 10%, so the loan modification (waiver of 6 months of interest and subsequent increase of the contractual interest rate) is considered to be a substantial modification.
- the legal fees are judged not to be incremental to the issue of the new debt, as they include elements relating to advice on the pre-existing debt’s contractual terms.
The initial liability has to be extinguished and a new liability recognised at its fair value as of the date of the modification. Given the market rate of interest is 12% for a comparable liability, the fair value of the liability amounts to CU 8,122,994. The difference of CU 1,877,006 between this initial fair value of the new liability and the carrying amount of the liability derecognised (CU 10,000,000) is recognised as a gain upon extinguishment. All fees incurred (CU 200,000) are immediately expensed, thus reducing the amount of the net gain upon extinguishment to CU 1,677,006.
Therefore, the following journal entries should be recorded:
Journal: | CU | CU |
Dr Existing liability | 10,000,000 | |
Cr New liability | 8,122,994 | |
Cr Cash (bank and legal fees paid) | 200,000 | |
Cr Profit or loss (gain on extinguishment) | 1,667,006 |
How Grant Thornton can help
Preparers of financial statements will need to be agile and responsive as the situation unfolds. Having access to experts, insights and accurate information as quickly as possible is critical – but your resources may be stretched at this time.
We can support you as you navigate through accounting for the impacts of COVID-19 on your business. Now more than ever the need for businesses, their auditor and any other accounting advisors to work closely together is essential. In this article is general information, not specific advice. However, if you would like to discuss any of the points raised, please speak to your usual Grant Thornton contact or your local member firm.